Chapter 7 - WHAT THE DEAD MEN ORDERED
Paolo Santini appeared on the video screen wearing a blue sweater and a face that had spent decades learning how not to reveal fear.
His attorney sat beside him. Two investigators joined from Italy. Karen Liu attended on behalf of Rosa as a potential witness whose family had been threatened. Alessandro and Matteo watched from separate rooms, each accompanied by independent counsel.
No one invited the press. No one arranged dramatic lighting. The truth, after so many years, arrived through a poor internet connection that froze whenever someone moved too quickly.
“My name was Paolo Santini,” the man began. “I have lived under another name since 1999. I understand that admitting this may expose me to prosecution. I am willing to give sworn testimony if my family is protected.”
The investigators asked him about the road above Naples where Elena Moretti had died. Paolo explained that Giovanni had ordered him to drive Elena to a meeting with Vincent Romano. A second vehicle followed them. When Elena demanded they stop, Paolo obeyed. She tried to leave on foot, but Vincent's men intercepted her.
“What happened afterward?” asked the Italian investigator.
Paolo looked down. “There was an argument. I heard Elena accuse Giovanni and Vincent of stealing a child. She said she had documents and would give them to a magistrate. One of Vincent's men struck her. I moved toward them. Giovanni ordered me back to the car.”
Alessandro gripped his attorney's notebook so tightly it bent.
Paolo went on. Elena had been injured, but conscious. Giovanni had ordered the men to place her back in the vehicle. Then, according to Paolo, they drove toward the coastal road while he was instructed to follow in another car. He saw Elena's vehicle go over the edge on a bend. He never saw who was driving when it happened.
“Are you claiming the crash was staged?” the investigator asked.
“I'm claiming I was told not to report what happened before it. Later, Giovanni told me the police would hear that I had been the driver and died with her. He arranged money and a new identity. If I refused, he said my wife and son would disappear.”
“Why come forward now?”
“Because my son found my old papers. He asked whether I was the kind of father who could let a woman die and pretend nothing happened. I couldn't answer him.”
There was no dramatic confession of murder. There were gaps, contradictions, and details requiring confirmation. The investigators questioned Paolo for hours about dates, vehicles, people, and payments. He supplied names of two men who might still be alive and a location where he had concealed an old notebook.
When the meeting ended, Alessandro sat alone for a long time. His father had not simply withheld facts about Elena. If Paolo's account held, Giovanni had participated in an event that led directly to her death, then helped disguise the result.
That evening he went to his mother's restored portrait in the archive. He had asked a conservator to repair the torn backing, but he had not rehung it. Elena's painted eyes seemed as gentle as ever. He spoke aloud without expecting a reply.
“I spent my life trying to be strong enough to be his son. I should have tried harder to be yours.”
Bruno appeared quietly at the doorway. “She would not have wanted you to carry everything alone.”
Alessandro turned. “You knew she feared Giovanni.”
“I knew she was unhappy. I knew your father controlled whom she saw. I didn't know about Matteo until after she died.”
“You were there.”
“Yes,” Bruno answered. “And I kept telling myself the way to protect you was to stay. I stayed so long I forgot that being loyal and being silent aren't the same thing.”
He took a folded letter from his jacket. “Elena left this with me the morning she traveled. She said to give it to you when you were grown, if the truth ever came out. I kept putting it off.”
Alessandro looked at the envelope, angry and grateful at once. He broke the seal.
My dear Ale, the letter began. If you are old enough to read this, you are old enough to know that courage is not the power to make people obey you. Sometimes courage means letting someone else say no. If you ever have a child, remember that love grows best in a home where no one has to be afraid.
He read the sentence three times. It sounded like something Rosa might have said. Perhaps that was why it hurt.
In Jersey City, Matteo received the translated testimony with his wife, Sofia, sitting beside him. Their daughter Ava, seven, was upstairs practicing piano. He had tried to imagine confronting the man who had stolen his childhood. Now he learned that the greater betrayal had come from people who had used him as a bargaining piece in a dispute over shipping routes.
“I thought my mother abandoned me,” he told Sofia. “Every birthday I tried to picture her deciding not to come.”
Sofia took his hand. “She tried.”
“I know that now. But the child I was didn't.”
They sat quietly for a while. Then Ava began playing the wrong notes upstairs, stubbornly repeating a measure until she got it right. Matteo smiled through tears.
“I'm going to tell her,” he said. “Not every awful detail. Just that her family includes people who loved each other and lost their way.”
Back in Chicago, Vincent Romano received word that Paolo had spoken with investigators. He dismissed two advisers, called a lawyer, and spent a long time watching his reflection in a dark window.
Isabella came to the office that night. She had heard the news from her attorney, who was helping her cooperate with the inquiry into the archive intrusion. She held a sealed package containing correspondence found in her father's private files.
“I found these,” she said. “They're copies of the letters Elena wrote to Teresa. You kept them.”
Vincent did not turn. “You're trespassing in my office.”
“Is it trespassing to look for the truth about the woman you used to frighten me with?”
“You know nothing about what it took to keep our family safe.”
“I know you let me believe the Morettis were our enemies because they were crueler than us. Now I think we were all working from the same ugly rulebook.”
He turned at last. “Hand me those papers.”
“No. I've already given copies to my attorney.”
Vincent stared at her. “You are my daughter.”
“Yes. And I'm tired of being told that means I must protect every decision you ever made.”
He laughed without humor. “Alessandro has turned you against me.”
“He hardly speaks to me. This is my decision.”
Vincent's expression softened briefly. “You will regret it.”
“Maybe. But I already regret the way I treated a three-year-old girl because I was frightened of what she represented.”
She left the package on the desk, withdrew her hand before he could touch it, and walked out.
At Marina's house, Rosa heard about Paolo's testimony from Karen. She felt no triumph. A dead woman had not been restored to life; Matteo's missing years had not been returned. What existed now was the possibility that official records would no longer tell a lie.
“Will Vincent be arrested?” Rosa asked.
“There's not enough information for me to promise that,” Karen said. “Investigators are reviewing jurisdiction, corroboration, and the surviving evidence. It may take time.”
“Good. Lily needs facts, not another powerful man announcing a verdict.”
Later Rosa called Alessandro. She told him about Lily's preschool application and asked whether he'd attend the open house as a guest. He sounded surprised.
“Would you be comfortable with that?”
“If you don't arrive with six men in black suits.”
“One suit. A normal one.”
“And no speeches.”
“I'll do my best.”
When he arrived, Lily took him by the hand and led him directly to the painting table. She showed him a picture of a big tree beside a little house. There were three figures near the door, plus a brown shape she identified as the dog and a purple shape she said was a very important potato.
Alessandro did not correct the proportions or ask why he was standing a little apart from Rosa and Lily. He simply said, “That's a beautiful picture.”
Lily grinned. “The potato lives with us.”
He laughed so suddenly that another parent looked over in surprise. Rosa watched from across the room and felt a cautious warmth spread through her. There might be no easy solution, but there could be a better way of beginning.
That night Helena called with news from the accountants. Giovanni's private account had paid Paolo, but several additional transfers went to an entity still active in New York. The account was controlled by a trust whose listed beneficiary was not Vincent or Giovanni.
It was a woman named Teresa Marino.
May you like
For twenty-six years, the friend everyone believed had vanished had been receiving money from the very men she was supposed to be hiding from.
And her most recent withdrawal had occurred that morning.
