Chapter 5 - Anna Had Disappeared on Purpose, but Not for the Reason I Expected.
The blood in Dr. Elise Morgan’s cabin belonged to no one in our family.
Police identified it as Elise’s.
She was alive.
Found twelve hours later at a clinic in Green Bay with a head wound and two fractured fingers.
No gunshot.
No mystery assassin.
She had been attacked while trying to keep two people from being taken.
Anna.
And Matteo.
There.
My brother was alive.
Not six years ago.
Now.
Detective Molina told me over the phone while Laura sat across my desk.
I did not speak for several seconds.
“Where?”
“Unknown.”
“Was he at the cabin?”
“Yes.”
“Confirmed?”
“Elise identified him.”
My hand tightened around the black ring.
“Did she say where they went?”
“No.”
“Can I speak to her?”
“No.”
Good.
The answer hurt.
Still good.
“She’s a witness and victim. We’ll decide access.”
I breathed.
“Understood.”
Marco stared at me as if I had become somebody else.
Maybe I had.
Then Molina added:
“Anna’s disappearance appears voluntary at first.”
My chest shifted.
“What does that mean?”
“She arranged to leave O’Hare through a freight exit. Dr. Morgan picked her up. Anna knew she was being watched.”
“So she ran.”
“Yes.”
“Without Lily.”
Molina paused.
“Apparently because Lily was safer if nobody knew where Anna was going.”
I closed my eyes.
Wrong.
Understandable.
Still wrong.
A mother disappearing without telling a six-year-old more than “go to the black ring if I don’t come back” was not noble just because danger was real.
Fear can explain a choice without making it good.
“What was Anna trying to do?”
“Meet Matteo.”
There.
“Why?”
“He contacted her three weeks ago.”
My heart stopped.
“How?”
“Encrypted email account they used years ago.”
“Why now?”
“He believed someone had located him and wanted Anna to move Lily.”
“Instead she left Lily behind.”
“Temporarily.”
The word sounded fragile.
Molina continued.
“Anna thought she could meet Matteo, get the ledger copy, hand it to federal investigators, and return before Lily knew anything.”
Of course.
Adults always believe children will not notice one night becoming two.
“What changed?”
“Someone intercepted at Morgan’s cabin.”
“Salvatore?”
“Likely connected. Not proven.”
Then:
“Matteo was injured?”
“Elise says he had an old limp, no new major injury before attack. During attack he helped Anna escape through rear door.”
My brother.
Alive.
Protecting Anna.
Gone again.
I stood.
Walked to window.
For six years I had imagined Matteo’s last moment as smoke and heat.
Now I had to replace that with six years of mornings I had never seen.
Breakfasts.
Jobs under another name.
Maybe birthdays.
Maybe fear every time a car slowed.
And one impossible question:
Why had he never trusted me enough to come back?
The answer might hurt more than the funeral.
Then Naomi called.
Lily wanted to know if her mother was alive.
We did not know.
Could we tell her Matteo was alive?
I asked Molina.
She said:
“Only what is confirmed and safe.”
Good.
So video call.
Lily wore pajamas with stars.
Rabbit beside her.
“Did you find Mommy?”
“Not yet.”
Her face dropped.
“But we found someone who saw her recently.”
“Who?”
I looked at Naomi.
She nodded.
“Dr. Elise.”
Lily’s eyes widened.
“Aunt Elise?”
There.
Of course she knew her.
“Do you know her?”
“She gives bad apples.”
I almost laughed.
“Did she see Mommy?”
“Yes.”
“Is Mommy hurt?”
“We don’t know.”
Good.
No false promise.
Then Lily asked:
“Did you find Uncle Matt?”
My throat closed.
“Yes.”
Her eyes became huge.
“He’s alive?”
“Yes.”
There.
She smiled.
Not shocked.
Of course.
She had never thought him dead.
Only gone.
“Can I see him?”
“Not yet.”
“Why?”
“Because we don’t know where he is.”
She frowned.
“He hides good.”
Apparently.
Then:
“Mom says he hides because your family lies.”
No child should have to deliver that sentence.
Still, she did.
“I think your mom was right.”
Lily looked surprised.
“Do you lie?”
“Sometimes.”
“Did you lie to Uncle Matt?”
I took time.
“I probably did about things I thought were family business.”
Good.
“Did you hurt him?”
That one.
“I don’t know.”
True.
“But I may have helped build the life he needed to escape.”
There.
Naomi watched.
Lily did not understand every word.
Good.
She only asked:
“Are you gonna make him come home?”
“No.”
The answer came easily.
That surprised me.
“No?”
“No.”
“If we find him, he gets to choose where he goes.”
There.
The black ring on my hand felt suddenly lighter.
Lily nodded.
“Okay.”
Then:
“Mommy too?”
“Yes.”
Good.
Adults choose.
Children need adults who come back.
Different.
Police reconstructed the cabin attack.
Three men arrived.
One was Hale Jr.’s associate.
Two connected to a private investigation firm that Salvatore used for years.
Their apparent goal was the ledger copy.
Not kidnapping Anna or Matteo for family reunion.
Documents.
They wanted evidence.
Anna and Matteo fled.
Elise stayed because she thought one attacker had gone toward the car where files were hidden.
She fought.
Got hurt.
The attackers took a laptop.
Not the ledger.
Where was ledger?
Matteo had no physical book.
He had digitized portions years ago.
Distributed copies.
Of course.
One with Anna.
One with Elise.
One somewhere else.
No single heroic evidence object.
Smarter.
Safer.
Then Elise told police one thing she insisted reach me.
Matteo did not trust DeLuca internal channels.
But he had planned to contact me after the evidence reached prosecutors.
Why?
Because of Lily.
Because Anna wanted her daughter to know family only if the family could no longer claim her.
That sentence cut.
Claim.
The DeLucas had always called blood obligation.
Matteo called it a claim.
Then police found Anna’s abandoned backpack near a bus station in Madison.
Inside:
Wallet.
Medication.
A child’s drawing.
And a note addressed to me.
Adrian,
If this reaches you, I made another bad plan because I thought I could keep Lily outside all of this for one more day.
Do not tell her I was brave.
Tell her I was scared and I chose for her when I should have asked for help sooner.
There.
Anna understood her own mistake.
Good.
Then:
Matteo is alive. He has been trying to undo what your father built without becoming another version of him.
If he refuses to see you, let him.
If he asks for you, go alone.
And one final line:
The ring was never proof you were safe.
It was proof you were the only DeLuca Matteo believed might stop when a child said no.
I sat with that sentence for a long time.
Not good.
Not safe.
Might stop.
A low standard.
Maybe the first real one I had ever earned.
The search for Anna exposed another mistake in my instincts.
I kept asking Detective Molina for updates.
Not unreasonable.
Too often.
On the fourth call she said:
“Mr. DeLuca, I will contact your attorney when there is something you are entitled to know.”
Entitled.
The word stopped me.
For years I had treated information as something power purchased automatically.
Where people lived.
Who they spoke to.
What they feared.
Now a missing woman’s investigation had boundaries that included me.
Good.
I told Laura:
“If I call Molina again without new information, hang up on me.”
She said:
“Gladly.”
That afternoon, instead of waiting over maps, I went into the kitchen.
Teresa was making soup.
She handed me onions.
“What am I supposed to do with these?”
“Cut them.”
“I have people.”
“That is the problem.”
Good.
So I cut onions badly while police looked for my brother.
Nothing about the act helped the investigation.
That was exactly why it helped me.
Not every hour of fear deserved a response.
Sometimes adults had to tolerate not knowing without turning uncertainty into orders.
While police searched for Anna, I finally asked Teresa what she remembered about Matteo before the fire.
“Everything you refused to notice.”
That sounded like her.
“What specifically?”
“He stopped attending Sunday dinners.”
“I noticed.”
“You called it disrespect.”
True.
“He sold his sports car.”
“I thought he wanted something quieter.”
“He closed two private accounts.”
“I thought he was moving money.”
“He was.”
She looked at me.
“Away from the life.”
There.
In hindsight, every sign had been visible.
I had interpreted each one through the only framework I trusted.
Disloyalty.
Weakness.
Secrets.
Never:
A man trying to leave without triggering the family that claimed leaving was betrayal.
Teresa said:
“He asked me once whether you would choose him if your father forced you to choose between Matteo and the organization.”
My throat tightened.
“What did you say?”
“I told him not to make me answer for you.”
Good.
“What did he think?”
“That you would choose the organization.”
I looked at my bare hand.
“Was he right?”
Teresa took too long.
“Back then?”
“Yes.”
“Probably.”
There.
No mercy.
Useful.
May you like
That night, when Molina called with the Iowa update, I understood why Matteo had walked into a sheriff’s office instead of calling me.
He had spent six years proving to himself that institutions, however imperfect, were safer than love without boundaries.
Related Stories
